Adult-Child-Health-and-Environmental-Support

47 million reasons to Donate to ACHES

Written by Ian Jarvis for ACHES ( Adult Child Health and Environmental Support)

The issue of the article

The current mesh or network of telecommunications structures and consequent Radiofrequency Radiation/Electro-Magnetic Frequencies at a variety of unknown and incalculable frequencies, strengths, pulsations, modulations, interactions and distances are relatively new in societal terms and have been building since only the 1990s and increasingly with 3G (from ~2003), 4G (from ~2010) and 5G (from ~2019).This has created unknown and incalculable effects to our atmosphere, especially at ground level and up to at least 60 metres high; increased by home, business and mobile ‘devices’ that Government at all levels (including Local Authorities) are encouraging, and in some cases almost forcing, the public and businesses to use.

Is there any human, animal or plant (omitting sub-divisions for brevity) that will NOT be affected in some way? That is all we can know just now, the future beyond the present is completely unknown and largely un-guessed since no-one appears to be paying attention to the medium or long term

[ – apart from Robert Kennedy jnr, US Government Health and Human Services Secretary, who, at the moment of writing this synopsis, is soliciting feedback from people specifically affected by such radiation and who has said that he will prepare a report into the “toxicity” of this radiation.]

Recognition

The whole purpose of a radio frequency base station 5G or 4G or a roof antenna is to radiate out telecommunications waves in a range of frequencies. That should not be a surprise to anyone and the only organisation that can give or withhold permission in the UK is the Council, the Local Planning Authority.

(Notwithstanding the possibility of an appeal – totally un-democratic if a single Inspector can override a Council and local people.)

The Question

The question of insurance, always on our minds, was raised to a new level when Wandsworth Council responded to an FoI request thus:

“Please would the Council send me the exact clause in their public liability insurance that shows that the Council is indemnified against claims on the Council for harm caused by emf radiation?

The reply was telling,

“The current opinion of the Council’s incumbent insurer is that such claims would not be covered under the Councils (sic) liability policy.”

We don’t know whether that Council has seen fit to investigate or to add such protection.

Where we are now

As the introductory paragraph illustrates, this sort of situation has been creeping up slowly. Our suspicion is that many LPAs have not realised the increasing risks associated with non-ionising radiation, across the locale, from structures that may be placed on council owned land and buildings, as well as on non-council sites, for which the council itself will have given permission. 

There is also the matter of other, related, risks such as battery fires, road traffic accidents, or collapse. In this article we are mainly concerned with radiation risks but are not ignoring any others.

This is the foundation for our basic claim; because of an industry wide exclusion over harm, injury or illness caused by EMF (eg Insurance Exclusion Clause 32 which you may see in some of your own insurances), any council (LPA) could become liable if such a claim were to be proven.

Could an industry exclusion be the reason for that answer by Wandsworth council?

Where would the liability lie? That is the big question. Could a council be faced with a huge financial liability? And is that risk mentioned in the Risk Register and Annual Governance Statement?

Can your council answer that single specific question? With references in its own insurance policy or policies?

If not then it could implicate staff and auditors in serious questions on governance and accounting. For example if the Annual Governance Statement has not indicated the specifics of insurance and not mentioned such risks as have been mentioned might it imply malfeasance in public office by responsible staff such as the Finance director or 151 Officer?

A key and powerful lever is that local and national government rely on ICNIRP. They say that as long as equipment conforms with the ICNIRP Guidelines, all is safe. But and it is a big BUT, ICNIRP specifically excludes from their guidance, people with any metal in their bodies. This would relate to people with pacemakers, metal fillings, hip replacements etc. If all the councils are not insured for EMF effects, that means they would not be covered if a person with any metal in their body makes a health claim against the council. A council would therefore have to underwrite this very real risk itself, which is a potentially huge financial challenge generally, for councils. This very real financial risk should be on the relevant risk register. The councils cannot argue that all is safe for everyone under ICNIRP guidelines and compliance, because such people are very specifically excluded from the ICNIRP safety guidance – and this is where the external auditor comes in. The external auditor might be invoked if this risk is not clearly identified on the register.

Retrospective

For some years now annual reports of insurance companies and telecommunications companies have included warnings that “EMF is an emerging risk” and indeed certain telecom companies make provisions in their annual reports for potential future claims.

It’s also worth recalling a tribunal hearing involving East Sussex County Council where the Council and school were charged with providing an Education, Health and Care Plan for a schoolgirl who was adjudged to be especially sensitive* to such radiation (wifi). The case process itself must have been expensive, involving, as it did, decisions by two local authorities, three hearings before the First-tier Tribunal, and two appeals to the Upper Tribunal. (ref UPPER TRIBUNAL CASE NO: UA-2022-000328-HS [2022] )

The judgement ruled that the girl must be educated in school without wifi but ensuring special facilities including a ‘low-wifi’ protected space and all that might entail, would not be an insubstantial cost to the Council, the school and thereby the taxpayer in the borough. Was that covered by insurance?

Conclusion

Ian’s team and we at ACHES are engaging with several Councils and the external auditors and responses have been mixed. Certainly to date there has not been a single reply such as, “yes we are covered, we know, and here are the clauses from the insurance.”

Most have been evasive or issued refusals to give specific information.

There is a way to go and we are not stopping.

Maybe you could gently ask your Audit Committee to look into it, or you could send an FoI in similar words to the one I mentioned earlier?

If you do, please email me the details and result to irj-4-wifi@outlook.com. The more I have the stronger will be my ACHES letter to the Secretary of State.

* This has been called Electro-Magnetic Sensitivity (EHS); now recently renamed Electromagnetic Radiation Syndrome (EMR-S) which more accurately illustrates the myriad of different health issues that people can suffer.